
The latest Nathan Hale Hazardous Tale tries to tackle the behemouth that is World War 2. This isn’t the first tale focusing on WW2 (see Raid of No Return about the pilots delivering the atomic bomb to Japan), but while Raid focuses on one snapshot of the war, this attempts to inform readers about Hitler and what led the Nazis’ rise to power, the first year of war, propaganda, Patton and his missions, the Black forces in the war, and notable figures like Vonnegut, Hemingway and Dahl.
Does Hale succeed?
If readers are a expecting a linear historical narrative, they are going to be frustrated and confused. This is one of Hale’s more creative books as he metaphorically illustrates the web of history with the history spider. Like a choose your adventure, each thread leads to a separate segment of the story. If you want to learn about the maniacal mustached guy, Hitler, go to page 45. If you want to know more about 1914 Europe, go to page 32. If you want to learn about the Stab in the Back myth go to 25. The Black corps in the army, page 62. And from those pages, the threads can intersect with other threads, options might lead readers to jump forward or back.
It is a visual illustration of how history is a web, and emphasizes Hale’s point that you can’t pinpoint WW2 (or history)’s beginning to one specific moment. It’s a build-up of multiple factors. I liked the sophiscation of the message and will encourage young readers to question more about history.
Questioning and critical thinking are a huge part of this book’s themes as Hale puts a lot of work in illustrating Hitler and his Inner Circle of Evil (Goebbles’ is particularly eerie) in the ugliest depicitions possible to drive home a point in the middle of the story abotu propaganda. This book could be considered propaganda as it depicts Hitler and his cohart as uglier than they were in real life in order to emphasize their evilness.
Hale, Hangman, Provost and Billy discuss this as it is artistic license but not propaganda because propaganda misconstrues facts to favor one side. The infrutable facts are Hitler is awful, and his actions were evil, no matter who you ask (unless you’re a Nazi but that’s a different discussion). It also discusses the difference between teaching and indoctrination (teaching encourages a person to question and think critically. Indoctrination is just obedience), and alligence to a country’s values vs a dictatorship.
One can easily see Hale drawing on the current issues of disinformation, hate, propaganda, and the like, but he never makes unsubtle parodies or potshots at the current landscape. He allows readers to draw those conclusions on their own which I believe is for the best as it encourages the reader to think for themself first rather than take umbrage at Hale’s presumably dislike for the current administration. It keeps readers who may be in a disinformation-filled enviroment from getting defensive and hopefully encourages them to look around more at the people they’re listening to or who their parents are supporting and come to their own conclusions.
There’s also plenty of fart humor for younger readers to keep them engaged, military history for the fanatics, and some adult humor that made me chuckle (“If you swear alliance to obey one person forever, you may be in a dictatorship” “Or a marriage.” π
Another great entry to the classroom and for the library shelves.
Leave a Reply