
Whitman Classics is a 60s imprint that brought abridged, illustrated editions of classic novels like Black Beauty and Little Women as well as licensed mystery series of popular Disney properties (Roy Rogers, Spin and Marty), westerns and girl sleuths. Annette was apparently a very popular Mousekateer on the Walt Disney Club and suitably joined the girl sleuth genre, all written by Doris Schroeder.
Annette is an orphan, raised by her aunt and uncle, and is a generally happy-go-lucky popular girl who hangs at the soda shop and has lots of friends. The novels are short, stopping at 200 pages except for the longer Sierra Summer, and has a loose continuity where one can figure out that The Mystery at Smuggler’s Cove must follow The Mystery of Moonstone Bay which was preceded by The Desert Inn Mystery. Where the other two fit in, no idea.
I got The Desert Inn Mystery at a flea market years ago so I have a soft sport for it despite its problematic stereotypes of Navajo as childlike, and/or silent worker with broken English. Same with the intense crush Annette’s friend, Lisa, has on an adult man that no one entertains as weird when he gives her romantic gifts. Except Annette who exclaims that he’s the same age as Lisa’s father! More amusingly, that adult man is the obvious villain of the piece and his name is Bill Gates. Since it came out in 1960s, it has no relation to tech mogul Bill Gates, but I found it funny.
Sierra Summer was a disappointment because it was almost the exact same plot as The Desert Inn Mystery including Annette almost being run off the road by the villain of the piece, the inclusion of stereotypical indigenous characters (although these are not explicity named as Navejo but another tribe in California), Annette and her friends fundraise to save their neighbor’s ranch and a prospector kidnaps the nerd character in order to find the buried treasure after faking his death. I get Schroeder probably had a formula to follow but yeesh, try more variety if it’s the same series.
The Mystery at Smuggler’s Cove was more unique even though she drags out Annette and her friend’s near drowning for half the novel, and how the boys make the stupidest decisions involving criminals just because he wants a refund on his boat. Then again, teen boys. There is more problematic portrayals of Hispanic characters (or at least unnamed Spanish island in the midst of a revolution) but at this point one has to accept that for vintage books.
Mystery at Moonstone Bay was most interesting and tightly-plotted, almost Gothic combing the troubles of new oil money and old money with scheming mothers, horse riding sabotage and Annette doing some real sleuthing instead of accidentally bumping into the mystery.
The Mystery at Medicine Wheel was written by a different person, Barlow Myers, and seemed like a lower-stakes version of Sierra Summer, and The Desert Inn Mystery where Annette works at a ranch in order to learn the value of money and ends up befriending a loner indigenous boy, John Running, who hates whites, a spoiled New Yorker who distrusts John, and when they all get kidnapped by an escaped convict/prospector (if you went by these books you’d think California was lousy with evil prospector/bank robbers) and all the races learn to get along.
Obviously not as twisty or iconic as Nancy Drew, but I find this and the rest of the original Whitman msteries to be fun in seeing how dated they are and the norms of the era they were written. It’s cheesy fun.
Leave a Reply