-
Book vs Movie: Howl’s Moving Castle

Now this is a case where the movie is infinitly more well-known than the book it originated from. Yes, I’m talking about the beloved Studio Ghibli film.
However, as I haven’t seen the movie I can’t say if it is better or what changes were made from book to screen. All I can say is that it’s a fun magical adventure, a bit like Alice in Wonderland, with a Beauty and the Beast romance and yes, Howl’s is so entertaining.
But that brings me to my bigger question. The age old question really, which is better original book or movie adaptations?
Usually the answer is obvious to me. Books. You can have more time inside the person’s mind and get in deep with their fears, insecurities and personal developments. Being in the character’s mind is always the best.
But sometimes the movie does do things better, I just can’t put my finger on how.
Is it just being able to put voice and image to the characters and seeing them in motion? Does the movie have the rare potential to go farther?
I don’t know what it is, but comment below if you think you do! -
New Covers
Ah yes, I have reached my 100th post (in 36 days no less)! I wrote this to almost catalogue all my favorite books over the years and to share thoughts and questions with fellow book lovers. Though I’m not sure how far reaching this (remember to comment so I know I’m not the only reading this thing), I’m posing another question that I always like to discuss with other book lovers.
New covers!
Now obviously new covers are issued because the book is popular so they insist on new editions with more fabulous art so on and etc. Other times I think it’s part of plot that they come out with new covers to trick people into buying a book they already have.
However, what I want to discuss is, if they’re making new book covers, why do they sometimes do it so badly?

For example, the new covers for the Bridgerton series are wonderful. They have a vivid, eye catching color palette. They feature a glimpse of the swoon-worthy couples. It’s gorgeous and a bit more entertaining than a romantic dreamy shot of some ornamental items.

However, other new covers totally go against what they’re trying to represent. The new editions of Dear America are one particular that grinds my teeth.
Look at this original one, it looks like a girl that has eaten and trudged through the dust of the prarie, she’s tired and windblown but she’s very real and arresting as she looks you in the eye.
Now look at this airbrushed one! Now I know the original one is taken from an acutal picture while this is a phto-realistic painting but they could have at least made her look like she was dirtied and tired instead of a prarie wife waiting at the homefront. It gives no hint to the hardships that Hattie faces on the Oregon Trail.
Now look at Christmas After All


If we first ignore how Minnie looks a Sims character with such a blank face, the loss of the sepia tone makes the book’s character less real. For me at least. The sepia photo was part of the charm, that it felt like a real diary using the same techniques that would have been in used in the 30s.
Next is The Royal Diaries. Luckily they only did two before abandoning the practice.


First off by losing the gold lining and hardcover, it automatically feels less royal and less like a diary. Second off, with the small font for the title, I truly thought this was a totally different book before I actually looked into the contents to realize it was one and the same.
Look also at the Anastasia one.


I chose a close up of the original so you can see the utmost detail and richness put into the original. You see the texture and thickness of the dress befitting the cold enviroment of Russia, you can see the lace decorating her front and the gilded decorations on the column behind her. In Marie Antoniette, you cannot see the cover here but if you had it in your hands you can see the flowers and birds decorating her wig. Basically it had detail to it, and emphasized the richness of the ladies. The new covers remind me of creepy porceline dolls.
I just don’t understand why they didn’t make art choices that would further emphasize the books gimmick of being historical diaries and instead of streamlined into something more generic. Okay, it’s probably generic in order to attract a wider audience but if they’re not into the content inside,t hey’re not going to buy it. And collectors of the series aren’t going t be willing to buy copies of the same book if they don’t like the art.
So what do you think? Is new art good or bad? If it ain’t broke, don’t do it? Or if they do it should it retain the same tone of the original?
Comment below! -
Top 5 Autobiographies
The Good Neighbor: The Life and Work of Fred Rogers by Maxwell King

I’ll confess something. I didnt watch Mister Roger’s Neighborhood. And the little I did watch, I found slow and boring so I didn’t really know or care about his life until I was an adult and my mom made me watch the new documentary on his life. From there I had to know more about this almost unbelievably kind man. King’s book is meticulously researched taking on interviews, documents, media appearances, and more stories from those who knew him intimately. It starts from the very beginning of the Roger family tree detailing their community works and how their faith played in a role in their life, and of course, Fred’s life. It continues to his life in college and work on Kid’s Tv where he began to firmly form his opinions on what children’s television should be, the child psychology/philosphy he followed and how he went on to create such a ground-breaking show that touched millions. It also tackles the myths and conspiracy theories that have popped up around Rogers. Don’t worry it doesn’t always put Rogers in a divine light, King also writes of his Roger’s brief homophobia before changing his mind. For you see, Rogers was a good man because he listened to others and was capable of changing and expanding his mind because in the end everyone is special.
(more…) -
Top 5 Archie stories
Now I’m sure you’re wondering, how can I have top 5 stories when the comics have thousands upon thousands of stories. Well I chose to pick my top 5 archie stories that are 2 or 4 parters. The ones that tend to have more of a storyline that made you need to pick up the next digest to find out what happens next.
“And the Winner Is. . . .”

This was literally the first ever Archie comic I owned so, it has a special place in my heart and my room. This five parter story was a take off the very popular blind date shows of the early 2000s where viewers would choose who the winner would be with. After breaking up with Reggie, Cheryl goes on The Lonley Hearts Club show to rub it in his face and get a new bf. Archie comics had readers introduced to Cheryl Blossom’s potential bfs, the athletic Austin, adorkable Brandon and talented George and we got to vote who won. Better yet, the winning boyfriend was actually relevant for a few years and made a cute relationship until the comics forgot and went for the old Archoe-Betty-Veronica-Chery rectangle again.
Funny Kind of Love

Another one of the “Real Look” stories that caused so much controversy when they first debuted. This time it was Reggie’s turn to shine, and shine it did as the book gave Reggie hidden depths utilizing his big mouth to win debates and catch the eye of brainy new girl, Bernadette Brown. It gave a softer side to Reggie, allowing readers to see why he loves to be class clown and also see him experience insecurity and awkwardness in this funny kind of love match pitting brains against witticisms. Thing was their relationship kind of worked and I wished they had continued it in some way.
Scarlet Knight Chronicles

I love Archie’s Weird Mysteries, the comics and the tv show which introduced the vampire, Scarlet Knight and her surprising twisting redemption from immortal bad girl to finding her humanity again thanks to the Riverdale gang. It was a fun series as it took on B-movie monster tropes with a classic dose of vampire mythology. And Scarlet was so popular that even after her four part story, she came back again to make one more sacrifice. . . Or so Archie and his friends believe.
Cyrano Jones

This four parter brings all the drama that Jughead could not want when the overenthusiastic new drama teacher insists that Jughead would be ther perfect guy to play needle nose Cyrano de Bergerac in the school play. However, this puts him in the middle of the girl drama that he so despises. Fighting his psychologist nemesis, Trula Twyst, the lingering looks of Sandy Sanchez (from the Real Look Matcmakers storyline) and playing Cyrano to Betty’s Roxanne (though the latter doesn’t have much drama since Betty is still very much Archie’s girl. Sorry Bughead fans)
Love me Baby, Mumbai

Oh yeah that cover alone provides so much drama for readers to salivate over. Me included. Especially since Raj provides actually pretty good competition to Archie as he can match her on a creative and intellectual level, and who wouldn’t want to be the muse of a future filmmaker? Well. . there’s a little more Archie-style miscommunication and misunderstanding involved but it is a fun romp when the Archies go Bollywood.
-
Ranking Forgotten History Books
I adore Ruta Sepetys’ Forgotten History books. They all have short two page or one page chapters which make it compelling to read as it always makes you want to turn the next page for more and before you know it, you’ve read 300 pages of emotional turmoil, resistance, spirit and heartbreak.
Now the Forgotten History series, just to be clear, aren’t connected. None of the characters pop up into others books mainly because they are from different times, and places. They’re only connected because they serve to illuminate forgotten or overlooked aspects of history like Soviet repression in the Baltics, the Romanian independence, Spanish resistance etc.

- Between Shades of Grey: This may be nostalgia talking but this was the first Ruta book I read and it is just a great introduction to her writing. Not only is poignant in how she portrays the continued resilience of the human spirit despite being encamped in Siberia, it shows also shows the nuances or the shades of grey as it will when it comes to survival and community in dire conditions.
- Salt to the Sea: Told through four alternating chapters of four refugees from Eastern Prussia trying to escape the German invasion and the Soviet march across Europe to get to freedom. However, their boat to freedom is the ill-fated Wilheim Gustoff. It is harrowing as you know the dire fate that is going to befall but I was compelled to read on to find out about the Nazi gold, the creepy twist on one of the Narrators and of course, to find out who survives.
- I Must Betray You: Her latest book is excellent story of the paranoia and distrust fueled by the Communist dictactor of Romania, Nicolae Ceasusescu who manage to out-Stalin Stalin in committing war crimes and torture on his own citizens. Christian is recruited into an extensive spy network when citizens spies against their own neighbors, family and friends under fear of punishment and hope for medicine for his ailing grandfather. But as the distrust continues, betrayals abound and he is exposed to Western news that Communism is falling across Europe, Christian finds the courage to take part in the independence protests.
- The Fountains of Silence: Much like the communist Eastern Bloc, Spain under Franco is full of distrust, torture for dissenters and poverty for most of the oppressed. It goes through the resistance and the fall out after the Spanish Civil War and the brave people who risk it all for love and freedom, if not for their futures, at least for future generations.
- Out of the Easy: While this was an interesting book exploring segregation, lower class living, an underlying mystery involving gangsters and pimps and prostitution in 1950s New Orleans, it doesn’t have the impressive scope of the others.
-
Book Tie Ins
Now I’m not talking about the junior novelizations of movies and tv show episodes. I’m talking about books that seek to expand the universe and give side characters their time in the limelight like the dozens of Star Wars books.
However, I never read or seen the full Star Wars trilogy so I don’t have the knowledge to discuss that.
I’m more thinking along the lines of Monster High’s Goulfriends Forever series. I was only 10 when it came out and immediately hooked on the cool designs and puns on famous monsters. I devoured all the webisodes and was so psyched for this book series when it came out. It expanded on the world inside, explored these side characters that are rarely given the limelight in the webisodes with unique backstories, even exes and secret dads plus an underlying mystery beneath it all. It was a great continuation of it all.

However, such tie-ins don’t always work. The YA Monster High series by Lisi Harrison was critiqued for its original character that stole the spotlight, the inclusion of too much human high-school drama and hijinks rather than embracing the freaky fabulous monsters and just not fitting in with the tone of the original.

However, others enjoyed the book for being a more mature, high school take on the characters, a darker and edgier alternate universe if you will.
So instead of the age-old question of whether tie-ins are a souless cash grab to make people buy more stuff, I ask should tie-ins honor the original, adding to the universe and sticking with the original essence and tone of the original content? Or should it explore the original in new creative ways and allow the author to put their personal stamp on it?
Or should it just be used to do the crossovers we all wanted because doing a movie would take too much money and Mattle politics.

Put your thoughts in the comments below!




